Hourly, Production or Commission? Choosing a Pay Plan for Landscape Crews

The plan types a landscape company can pay crews, techs and foremen with (hourly, production, bonuses, commission) and the wage-hour mechanics every one of them triggers.

FLSA floor for covered employers; a higher state or local rate applies where one exists

Federal minimum wage

$7.25/hour

Each workweek stands alone — hours are never averaged across weeks

Overtime trigger

Past 40 hours in a workweek

Regular rate = total weekly earnings ÷ all hours worked

Piece-rate overtime

Half the regular rate per overtime hour

Weekly earnings must at least equal the offered hourly wage, topped up if short

H-2B piece-rate pay

Weekly guarantee required

Every landscape crew pay plan, whether hourly, production, piece-rate, bonus or commission, has to clear the same federal floor of $7.25 per hour for employers covered by the FLSA. That floor also includes overtime past 40 hours in a workweek and a regular rate that includes promised bonuses and commissions. This guide breaks down the pieces of a landscape crew pay structure, the overtime mechanics each piece triggers, and how the choice fits each role on your roster.

Hourly pay

Hourly pay is the plan where the records and the wage are the same thing: the crew clocks time, you pay for it, and the hours log doubles as the pay calculation.

Straight time covers the first 40 hours of a workweek, and every hour past 40 owes an overtime premium in that same week.

Hours are never averaged across weeks.

Hourly time also lines up with what federal rules already count as hours worked.

Travel from job site to job site during the workday is hours worked, and so is the drive from a required meeting place (the shop where crews pick up tools or instructions) to the first job.

Ordinary home-to-work travel is not hours worked.

Required meetings and training are paid time too: a tailgate safety talk before the trailers roll is work, not a free extra.

An hourly structure captures all of it without a separate calculation.

The minimum-wage check is simple under hourly pay: the rate has to clear the federal floor of $7.25 per hour, or the higher state or local minimum where one applies.

Add a production or commission layer on top and the regular-rate mechanics in the sections below start to apply.

The tradeoff is that pay tracks time rather than output, so slow traffic, short stops and rain-shortened days cost the same hours as productive ones.

That is the reason companies layer production incentives onto an hourly base rather than replacing it outright.

Production and piece rate

Production and piece-rate pay tie earnings to completed work instead of hours: a fixed amount per mowed property, per finished cleanup, per planting or hardscape section completed to standard.

The unit is yours to define, and the amount per unit has to come out of your pricing; how to price landscaping jobs is the companion decision on the revenue side.

Paying by the piece never switches overtime off.

For piece-rate and production-paid workers, the regular rate is total weekly earnings (piece earnings plus production bonuses) divided by all hours worked that week, and each hour past 40 earns an extra half of that regular rate on top of the week's earnings.

That math needs hours, so piece-rate crews get time records exactly like hourly crews.

Federal recordkeeping rules require, for every non-exempt employee, hours worked each workday and each workweek, the pay basis, and straight-time and overtime earnings.

The rules demand accurate records, not any particular app or method.

H-2B crews carry an extra condition: they may be paid piece rate or production pay only if the employer guarantees weekly earnings at least equal to the offered hourly wage and tops up any shortfall in that same workweek.

The wage floor under an H-2B job is the highest of the prevailing wage or the federal, state or local minimum wage, and it applies to U.S. workers in corresponding employment too.

If you promise a production bonus on top of piece earnings, the bonus is part of the regular rate, not a separate envelope.

That is the next section's subject.

Crew bonuses

Bonuses let an hourly or production plan aim at a target: production bonuses for completed work, attendance bonuses for showing up through the season, retention bonuses for coming back next spring, referral bonuses for bringing in a new hire.

What to reward, how much, and on what trigger are your design decisions, set against your own budget.

Our research found no benchmark amounts to copy.

The rules attach to how a bonus interacts with overtime, not to its size.

Bonuses promised in advance to induce workers to produce more, work more efficiently or stay with the company (production, efficiency, attendance and retention bonuses) are not discretionary, and they must be included in the regular rate when overtime is computed.

Commissions count in the regular rate the same way, whatever their amount or frequency.

Referral bonuses get their own line in the same rule.

A referral bonus can stay out of the regular rate only if the fact and the amount are decided at your sole discretion at or near the end of the period and were never promised in advance.

A published program with fixed amounts and conditions is a promise, and it goes into the regular rate like any other promised bonus.

The practical consequence shows up in the overtime bill, not the bonus line: once a promised bonus is in the regular rate, overtime premiums ride on the higher rate.

Budget the incentive with overtime in it, not bolted on after the fact.

Commission for techs and sales

Commission fits roles where pay should track sold work: sales representatives winning new accounts, account managers selling enhancements into the properties you already maintain, and route techs who add services from the truck.

BrightView's fiscal 2025 10-K describes one large contractor's version of the split: account managers focused on retention and enhancement sales at each maintenance branch, plus 1-2 dedicated business developers for winning new customers locally.

The percentage, any draw against future commission, and what counts as a sale are plan design, yours to set against your own margins and market.

Whatever split you choose, the wage-hour rules attach to it the same way they attach to a bonus.

Commissions are part of the regular rate for overtime purposes, whatever their amount or frequency.

For a tech earning an hourly base plus commission on add-ons, the commission goes into the weekly earnings that set the regular rate, and the overtime premium is computed on that combined rate.

A commission plan does not replace hours records either: non-exempt employees paid by commission still need daily and weekly hours recorded, and every hour past 40 in a workweek still earns its premium.

For salaried sales or account-management roles, the exemption question turns on the duties test and the salary level — the next section's subject.

Choosing a plan per role

Let the work choose the plan.

Hourly pay suits crew members on maintenance and install work, where the day's time is real even when the output varies, and production incentives layer cleanly on top when you want pace on mowing routes or install milestones.

For foremen, the hourly-versus-salary choice changes pay predictability, not the overtime test.

A foreman who spends the week on a mower, in a trench or behind equipment controls is owed overtime however the pay is labeled; a salary only reaches the exemption test at the $684-per-week salary level plus the duties test.

Route-based lawn techs have the widest menu: hourly, production pay per completed stop, commission on add-on sales, or a hybrid of all three.

Every layer carries the same mechanics — hours records, a regular rate that includes the incentive pay, and premiums computed week by week.

Hourly pay also fits roles the customer effectively buys by time — irrigation service calls, backflow tests, fertilization and pesticide rounds — where the visit's length moves with the site rather than with a unit count.

Salaried pay shows up again in superintendent, operations-manager and office roles, where the duties genuinely run to management.

Even there, the salary level and the duties test decide the exemption case by case; a salary alone never makes a role exempt.

Whatever you pick, the test is whether you can operate it every week: accurate hours, incentives budgeted into the regular rate, and premiums computed in the week they are earned.

Pay structure is one piece of hiring and running a landscaping company; the checklist below pulls the decision into six questions to answer before you commit.

Employer information, not legal, tax or insurance advice. Wage and hour rules are federal and state law, and they change; confirm your pay plan with the U.S. Department of Labor's Wage and Hour Division, your state labor agency or employment counsel.

Questions to answer before you commit to a plan

  • Can you record every hour the plan will generate (site-to-site travel, shop meetings, training) accurately, every week?
  • Does the overtime math have the hours it needs, even under a piece-rate or commission plan?
  • Is every promised bonus and commission inside the regular-rate budget, with overtime computed on the higher rate?
  • For any H-2B crew, is the weekly earnings guarantee built into the production or piece-rate plan?
  • Is anyone on salary doing manual production work? A salary alone does not make them exempt; the duties test and the $684-per-week level decide.
  • Have you checked what your own state adds to the federal rules (daily overtime, where a state requires it) with your state labor agency?

Questions employers ask

Can I pay my landscape crew piece rate instead of hourly?

Yes, with the wage-hour rules intact. Piece-rate and production pay still require hours records, and overtime is computed on a regular rate (total weekly earnings divided by all hours worked) with an extra half of that rate paid for each hour past 40, on top of the week's earnings. H-2B workers can be paid piece rate only if weekly earnings are guaranteed to at least the offered hourly wage, with any shortfall topped up that week.

Do production bonuses and commissions count toward overtime?

Yes, bonuses promised in advance (production, efficiency, attendance and retention bonuses) count toward overtime as part of the regular rate, and commissions count in it whatever their amount or frequency. A bonus can stay out only if it is truly discretionary: fact and amount decided at the employer's sole discretion at or near the end of the period and never promised. A published referral program with fixed amounts and conditions is a promise.

Is a salaried landscape foreman exempt from overtime?

It depends on the foreman's duties: salary alone never makes a foreman exempt from overtime. The white-collar overtime exemptions do not apply to manual or blue-collar work, so a foreman who spends the week running equipment or working in the field is owed overtime however highly they are paid. An exemption requires pay on a salary basis of at least $684 per week plus the duties test.

Do I have to pay for drive time between job sites?

Yes, travel from job site to job site during the workday is hours worked, and so is the drive from a required meeting place (the shop where crews pick up tools or instructions) to the job. Ordinary home-to-work travel is not hours worked. Required meetings and training count as paid time, including tailgate safety talks.

What is the minimum wage for landscaping employees?

The federal minimum is $7.25 per hour for employers covered by the Fair Labor Standards Act; where a state or local minimum wage is higher, the higher rate applies. States can also require daily overtime (California's starts after 8 hours in a day, for example), so check your state labor agency's rules alongside the federal ones before you set a pay plan.

More hiring resources

Need crew members to pay?

Once the plan is set, list the opening. LandscapingHires is where crew members, foremen and lawn techs look for their next crew. Post the role with the pay structure spelled out.